Michael Pence, Jr., 24 of Stephensburg, and Josh Huff, 19 of Big Clifty, were arrested after allegedly stealing property from a car and abandoned house owned by James Alexander, then storing the stolen property in a field owned by the same man.
Alexander found the property and saw the men as he was leaving the field to call the authorities.
Hammons and Pagan were notified at 9:49 a.m. and wrapped up the case by 2:30 p.m.
Police said Pence and Huff had boasted of their misdeed to another person in the Big Clifty area, then allegedly stole $10 from that person.
Officers said two witnesses identified the men with written statements.
Both were lodged in the Grayson County Detention Center. Bond has been set at $5,000 each.