Fatcow Icon
Amish buggies to remain without orange reflectors
by Theresa Armstrong Reporter tarmstrong@gcnewsgazette.com
Apr 27, 2011 | 11950 views | 3 3 comments | 14 14 recommendations | email to a friend | print
The familiar Amish horse and buggy parked outside the Grayson County Courthouse was an interesting sight on Thursday morning April 21.
The familiar Amish horse and buggy parked outside the Grayson County Courthouse was an interesting sight on Thursday morning April 21.
slideshow
An Amish buggy and horses were parked quietly outside the Grayson County Court House early Thursday morning while the owners were inside facing charges.

After a citation was issued by Leitchfield Police Officer Tim Moutartier to Joe Hostetler, of Park City, for failing to display the slow moving emblem on his Amish Buggy while driving it on city streets, Hostetler appeared in district court Thursday morning.

Hostetler argued that to put these emblems on his buggy would go against his religions beliefs.

That citation will sit in district court waiting for a decision by the higher court before any action is taken.

Because there are two similar cases currently awaiting a ruling from the Kentucky Court of Appeals, Grayson County Attorney Clay Ratley agreed to hold the case over until August.

“It just make sense to hold the case because the decision by the higher court will directly effect what happens in our court,” said Ratley. “We have received numerous complaints about the buggy’s not having the orange emblems on them but the buggies do have grey reflective tape on them.”

The Kentucky Court of Appeals heard oral arguments on March 24, in two appeals from a group of Amish men who say the state law requiring them to display a slow-moving vehicle emblem on their horse-drawn buggies violates their religious freedom.

The nine Amish men from Graves County are appealing their misdemeanor convictions for failing to display the slow-moving vehicle emblem on their buggies.

The men, who were convicted in Graves County District Court, are arguing that state law KRS 189.820 mandating that they display the emblem, goes against their church’s teachings.
Comments
(3)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
bodine01
|
May 01, 2011
They're going to slow for a reflector to make a difference. They need a strobe light, but if they don't want one that's fine with me. I just don't think we should be held responsible if we hit them. They should be held accountable for the damage done to me and mine.
justmerosie
|
April 30, 2011
I really have a problem with this, another form of prejudice, in my book. Whether you have a horse and buggy or a car, and if you are in a position to make what you are doing a safety issue, then I think they should be required to take precautions; you would think they would WANT their family to be safe!!! And while we're talking about it, I believe that all buggies should be licensed and insured, they cause and are part of accidents too. Different strokes for different folks is what divides our country. I believe in their beliefs about automotive vehicles, electricity, telephones...these are all choices; but when you ride the public roadways, you ride with all of us who have rules too. I have a hard time believing that a reflective sign is against one's religion; my God says I will be here for you, but you need to be responsible for yourself too. Come on, get off your high horse; you are not a selected few!
Cday138
|
April 27, 2011
Someone please explain why a orange reflector goes aginst their religeon? czilla138@yahoo I can not imagin how this is a religeous argument. It is pure safty. if im driving at night your black painted buggy needs to be seen somehow.
Weather
Sponsored By:

Lottery
Sponsored By:

Stocks
Sponsored By:

Gas Prices
Sponsored By:

Featured Businesses
Recipes
Sponsored By: